CLICK HERE to see all openings for your dates

Montego Bay
- 5 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms in Anna Maria, FL

Availability and Booking

Click on the calendar to select Check In and Check Out dates. This requires 2 clicks to select your date range.
Available Date
Unavailable Date
Selected Dates
Arrival Date:  
Number of Nights:  

For a customized vacation experience:

Check Out the My AMV App!

At A Glance

  • On our Professional Linen Service Program
  • Elevated luxury property
  • 5 bedrooms and a den, 4 full bathrooms
  • Rooftop deck with beautiful views of the Island and the Gulf
  • Private heated pool with spa, covered lanai, BBQ grill, tropical landscaping, 6 bikes and 2 beach carts
  • 4 Kings, 1 Bunk bed (Twin over Double)-Sleeps up to 12
  • Just a short 2 minute stroll to the Gulf Beaches
  • Close to local restaurants and shops and Pine Avenue
  • Poolside TV, Xbox gaming system, Wireless Internet and more


Montego Bay

211 Magnolia Avenue

Anna Maria, Fl 34216

Montego Bay is a luxury home that is located on the prestigious North end of Anna Maria Island. This professionally decorated property offers 5 bedrooms, plus a den upstairs, and 4 bathrooms--with 2 Master suites. This fabulous home comes with many great amenities including a private heated pool with a spa, covered lanai, bikes, multiple decks--but best of all--a rooftop deck with stunning views of the Island and Gulf waters!

It doesn't stop there--the tropical backyard features a pool side flat screen TV. Enjoy quality time together and gather around the dining area by the pool and after the sun sets--enjoy the beautiful Florida nights in the pool or spa. It doesn't get better than that.

One of the many highlights of this home is the location--you are just a short 2 minute stroll to the world renowned white sandy beaches of the Gulf of Mexico and less than a 1 minute walk to the beloved and quaint Ginny and Jane's restaurant. Other great local eateries and shops are just around the corner--you are located close to it all yet still removed enough from the hustle and bustle for a relaxing getaway. No need to rent a car or turn yours on if you are driving to this beautiful destination-explore the Island by foot, bike or take advantage of the free Island Trolley Service!

This property participates in our Professional Linen Program. In Anna Maria Vacation's continuous effort to bring only the best quality experience to our guests, we are proud to offer a professional linen service at this property to better enhance your enjoyment while staying here. This luxury amenity provides you high quality linens that are in place and ready for your use upon your arrival. These high-quality linens are washed in a commercial setting using the latest and best technology.

Take the fuss and worry out of packing your private sheets and beach towels knowing that when you arrive to your dream vacation rental, in place are high quality and commercially cleaned luxury bedding, bath towels, wash clothes and beach towels ready for your stay. Eliminate the guessing game, free up luggage space and breathe easy knowing that everything is already taken care of for you. This same philosophy extends even to your departure- nothing to wash, dry, fold or having to fool with trying to squeeze into an already tightly packed suitcase! A fantastic "must have amenity" for your AMI vacation experience.

With something for everyone to enjoy--this home is sure to be a hit with everyone in your traveling party. Whether you are looking to relax by the pool, explore the 7 mile stretch of beaches or live as the locals do by visiting the local eateries and shops!

Bedrooms & Bathrooms

There are 5 bedrooms, with 2 Master suites, and 4 bathrooms and a den upstairs.

The main living level includes 3 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms--there are 3 King bedrooms on this level. Here you will find one of the two Master suites. On the upper living level, you have the den as well as the remaining two bedrooms including the second Master suite. The sleeping arrangements include 4 King sized beds and 1 Twin over Double bunk bed. This home comfortably accommodates a group of 11.


Start your day off by enjoying your morning coffee on one of the balconies or the rooftop deck as you don't plan your day-after all you are on vacation on a tropical island. Leave the planning behind and sit back and relax! Enjoy the tropical backyard adorned with a private heated pool, spa, BBQ grill and covered lanai or enjoy the brisk 2 minute stroll to the beautiful beaches. With its wonderful location-you are close to it all. From local shops and restaurants, to the beaches and more!

** If you would like to have your pool heated, we kindly ask that you please contact AMV at least 10 days prior to your arrival so that it ensures us ample time to fulfill your request. We do offer pool heat as needed as a courtesy to our guests at no additional charge. All of our pools and pool equipment are closely monitored by the pool company for your safety, we kindly ask that the controls not be tampered with- most of the systems are locked for this reason. Due to the island's strict 10pm noise ordinance, the pool heaters will not run overnight. Please remember, outdoor spas are not hot tubs (some properties have a spa, some have a hot tub). Generally speaking, our winter months are considered from November through April. During these months we do our best to ensure that the pools are heated to a temperature of 82 degrees. However, please be aware that even in Central Florida we do occasionally get cold spells that can send the temperatures down into the 30's for a few nights in a row. This will cause the pool water temperature to draw down to in the 70's and a pool pump will automatically shut down if the outside temperature gets too cold. The pump will then kick back on in the morning and begin re-heating of the pool back to 82, which may take several days depending on the severity of the cold spell. Ultimately, these situations are beyond our control. Other issues such as severe weather conditions, equipment malfunction, temporary loss of use of equipment or amenities due to maintenance purposes or other items do happen for time to time. Please be aware that AMV cannot issue refunds during your stay based on acts of God. However, please know that in the rare event of pool equipment malfunction during your stay, AMV will do everything in our power to expedite repairs as quickly as possible as we certainly want you to enjoy your heated pool and Florida sunshine to the fullest extent possible! Anna Maria Vacations thanks you in advance for your understanding on this issue.


Request Information


Great stay!

By: Trip Date: 10/04/2018

This house is beautiful, well, maintained and spacious. The upstairs has a kids room and small den that was a great playroom. 2 blocks from Sandbar Restaurant, Pine Street, and about 2 minute walk to the beach. The pool was a nice size and thr outside living area was large. Wish there was a TV visible from the table down there.
Only major complaint: the curved, metal staircase that leads to the pool. It is open and dangerous. We had to out a chair under it because both kids and adults hit their heads on it. It needs to be closed off. Also, the pool equipment is RIGHT THERE and really loud when you’re swimming or enjoying the patio. We would stay again. 5 adults, 4 kids.

Hi Kate,
Thanks for the awesome review of Montego Bay! We appreciate the kind words and glad it was spacious enough for everyone. Happy to hear you all enjoyed the kids rooms, the location, and the pool area! We are sorry to hear about the staircase and happy to pass that along to the appropriate department. We’re glad you enjoyed your time here and hope to have you back soon!

Family Vacation

By: Trip Date: 08/05/2017

This is a nice home but renters beware. We have used this rental company before and are finding their lackluster customer service with issues we had. They ask you to download the app so all information can be sent you however upon our arrival a code is supposed to be sent to the renter thru the app so that keys can be obtained for the home. That required our first call to the rental company. We were told we could not get in before 4 as it needed to both be cleaned and inspected. We did wait until the appropriate time and finally entered the home only to find beer bottles, bottle caps, snack bags and garbage all around the pool. Since we had traveled all day we just picked it up and threw it away so we could swim. When we entered the living space in this home there clearly was still sand on the floor and on the step that led to the upper level. Again, we didn’t complain as we were told the cleaning crew had been there and it had been inspected. Our 10 month old Grandaughter had dirty knees all week we were there. There is a cheap vacuum that we tried to use but it did nothing. On day 2 we noticed the spa to the pool would run for about 2-3minutes and shut off. No heat, no bubbles. The pool guy had been there the day before and had told us he would be back the next day. That set up an everyday call by us to see what was going to happen with it and my husband and I leaving our cell phone number for them got call us back. I also made them aware of the cleaning issue and they asked if I had taken pictures. Um no, we cleaned up the garbage ourselves. On Thursday the pool guy returned and the spa was unfixable and they would need to contact the owner for further repairs. Everyday I was told someone would get back with us…..no one did. On Friday (our last day) I was told the owner had not yet agreed to the repairs as he wanted to see if it was still under warranty. Needless to say nothing ever was resolved. We we got home on Saturday we had a message on our home phone for us to call them. I called on Sunday and spoke with the answering service who said the would relay the message and someone would call us back. Well today I called back and basically after 45 minutes of going round and round with the girl on the phone, she assured me she would call me back after a meeting that they were going to have and discuss our issues. She reiterated that I should have taken pictures and asked to have the house cleaned again. I told her I guess I was just to nice when we arrived and just picked it up but once we had issues is when I expected some service. We vacation in AMI about once or twice a year and are coming with a group in February which we were planning on suggesting this house but it definitely won’t happen now. I get it things break down. But the customer service rep told me it wasn’t like the spa not working ruined my trip I could still use the spa. Well yes that’s true it didn’t ruin my trip! I wouldn’t let that happen. However, when you rent a home so you can use a spa and it doesn’t work you expect something for your inconvenience. All I asked for was a credit for the cleaning fee since the house wasn’t clean. We also had a bathtub drain that had hair in it and was clogged with a slow drain all week. We were also told the home owner doesn’t give any credits. Well that’s fine but agree to fix the issues! If you are going to own a million dollar home for rental income you better be willing to fix the issues that come up. There are plenty of rental company’s and plenty nice homes so please just we aware of these issues.

Hello Janet,
Thank you for reaching out to us regarding your stay at Montego Bay.  We are very sorry to hear that you are not happy with your stay this year.  The check-in time is 4 pm and your key code is active at 4 pm for privacy purposes. Our records show that we responded to all of your requests such as delivering an additional frying pan and sending our service staff to tend to the spa.  The pool vendor that takes care of the pool and spa at Montego Bay was sent out as well and reported to us that a part needed to be replaced.  We have been in touch with you numerous time during your stay and called the number you provided us on your profile, which happened to be your home phone number.  Please note that all of our homes are inspected prior to each guest arrival and no cleaning issues were reported prior to your arrival.  Cleaning issues were never mentioned to us when you contacted us, this is why we asked if you could provide us with pictures that we then could forward on to the housekeeping team.
We feel that we have honored all of our requests and appreciate your understanding that you are renting a privately owned home and that equipment issues unfortunately can and do come up.  As a courtesy to you as our valued guest, we have honored your request and have offered to refund you half of your cleaning fee back.
We hope you were otherwise able to enjoy your stay and we hope to have you stay with us again for your future Anna Maria Island vacation needs!